|
The Conspiracy of Ignorance: The Failure of American Public Schools | 
| Author: Martin L. Gross Category: Book
List Price: $25.00 Buy New: $7.45 You Save: $17.55 (70%)
New (5) Used (6) from $3.99
Rating: 38 reviews Sales Rank: 1647225
Format: Bargain Price Media: Hardcover Pages: 291 Number Of Items: 1
ASIN: B00007E9RW
Publication Date: September 1999 Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
| |
| Also Available In:
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Amazon.com Review Martin L. Gross has made a career out of books that attack "the establishment," whether it be the medical community (The Doctors) or the general powers that be (The Government Racket). In The Conspiracy of Ignorance, he takes aim at a lumbering, elephant-sized target: public education. Armed with statistics and research papers--the Third International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) and the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) being his most prominent sources--Gross rails against the declining performance of U.S. students. While his criticisms--which encompass everything from teachers' unions to "useless" education degrees, PTAs, psychological services in schools, even honor roll bumper stickers--are not new, they make an imposing indictment when presented all together. Gross poses a number of radical solutions, including the elimination of undergraduate schools of education (replaced by a one-year postgraduate course that prepares scholars to become teachers in their specialty). He believes the entire education system should--and can--be overhauled without spending any more than at present. One of his suggestions to make funds available for reform is to cut support personnel, but he doesn't address how schools would then clean themselves without custodians or how high school crime would be affected by the loss of security guards and police officers. While Gross's tendency to use his own high school experience as a model of excellence grows tiresome, his points are well taken. The Conspiracy of Ignorance will have you either nodding in agreement or aching to wring the author's neck. --Jodi Mailander Farrell
Product Description
In this global age of information, nothing should alarm American parents and leaders more than the failure of our public schools. As quality education of the young becomes the true international currency, that commodity--unfortunately--is in grievously short supply. American schoolchildren lag far behind students in most of the developed world, scoring nineteenth out of twenty-one countries in a recent math competition. On domestic exams, almost forty percent are reading at "below basic" levels. In this candid, provocative, and comprehensive study of the public school system, from kindergarten through high school, bestselling author Martin L. Gross charges that the Education Establishment has nurtured a conspiracy of ignorance that promotes and defends lower standards of teaching and learning designed to maintain its monopoly on our public schools. The verdict is in: The teaching vocation has failed to produce competent teachers, penalizing its 45 million public school students. The problem is that the Establishment--from a tight group of teachers, principals, superintendents, education professors, and counselors, to the state commissioners of education--selects mainly academically inferior teacher candidates, and ignoring time-tested fundamentals, trains them in such dubious concepts as "educational psychology" and a "whole language" method of reading that ignores proper grammar and spelling. In a series of shocking revelations, Mr. Gross describes how the typical teacher learns little more than a two-year community college graduate; how the average college-bound student scores fifty points higher on his SAT exams than most of his teachers; how the great majority of school teachers are less trained in their own specialties than other college graduates in the same field; and how "untrained" teachers in both private and public schools perform better than Establishment graduates. The usual remedies--from federal aid to smaller class sizes--have done nothing to alleviate these problems because they make no attempt to challenge the Education Establishment's control. In a powerful Bill of Indictment, Mr. Gross shows how the teaching vocation, aided by its unions, maintains a self-perpetuating cycle of low performance, and he offers his own detailed prescription for change that will raise public education to the level our children--and society--need and deserve. The Conspiracy of Ignorance is a lucid, persuasive argument based on a wealth of research that asks the questions most education observers are afraid to ask. It is a book desperately needed to ensure that American schoolchildren will have a chance to prosper as educated and productive citizens in today's world.
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 33 more reviews...
Why Aren't There More Thinkers Like Martin L. Gross? October 24, 2008 Mike Gross rightly points out how the "Education" field is saturated with theories of learning and no substance. The value of rote learning has essentially disappeared. Instead, the "Education" degree is saturated with Psychological Theory, which is predicated on theories of human nature. The most prominent self-theory to grace the halls of K-12 public schools is Carl Roger's "Self-Esteem" myth. Gross rightly said: "The teacher has now assumed more the model of the social worker or even amateur psychologist. Not knowledge, but superior human relations, a sense of self-confidence--'self-esteem' again--and a stronger, warmer rapport among teacher, parent and child have become a new criteria" (page 13). This is an issue worth tackling on many levels. While the classical learning of the 19th-century may be impractical on some levels, the psychological modal offered in today's public school system has gone to the other extreme. There are many factors that go into education; parenting is certainly one of them. Nonetheless, the fact that one can teach at the college level and yet not at the high school level because they don't have "certification" from the Education department (i.e. psychological society) is simply asinine. The soothsaying influence of psychology, as espoused in Human Growth and Development classes, where mind sciences set the precedent for curriculum, stifle real learning with theories about how people learn (i.e. where rote learning is thrown to the wayside). Why? Because they are deemed to know the mysteries of the mind. What a fraud! This is sad . . . especially when considering how public schools get worse by the year while those with substantial degrees (be it in real disciplines like Biology, English, Math, or History) are more likely to teach in a private school or at the collegiate level. This was one element of the book that Martin L. Gross should receive a standing ovation for daring to touch upon. Another book that could be read side by side with this one is Gross' The Psychological Society; the research in this book shows how unreliable and unscientific psychology and other branches of the mind sciences really are. In spite of this, mind "sciences" impact (at least North America) every level of society from education to the Halls of Congress. It would be wonderful if more people, like Gross, were willing to ask tough questions while refusing to be obsequious to so-called "experts."
A Blueprint For Saving The Public Schools April 2, 2008 Bruce Deitrick Price (Norfolk, Va.) 2 out of 2 found this review helpful
Please note: all the 35+ reviews for this important book ended up under the paperback version. I took the liberty of putting my review in both places, lest anyone think this book didn't inspire any reviews.... Martin Gross provides a passionate, fact-filled investigation of the problems in the public schools at all levels. He has chapters on the training and licensing of teachers, the dumbed down curriculum, the psychologized classroom, the value of charter schools, the hope of alternative certification, the dead weight of the NEA, the betrayal by the PTA in many communities, and much more. Gross finishes with an excellent 19-point reform plan, which includes these items: modify tenure laws, close all undergraduate schools of education, regulate teacher unions, award more vouchers, disband the national, state and local PTA, and increase alternative certification. Gross points out that: "In inflation-adjusted dollars, we are now spending two to three times more per child than in 1960, when performance was generally higher.... "It is hard for laypeople to understand the level of intellectual blindness that dominates the education profession... "Are students and society better off with the weaker student-centered education of today? Only if we want to accept the trade-off of being among the most ignorant nations in the world... "The education professor in Connecticut whom I interviewed denigrated facts--or knowledge--as `trivia,' claiming that the main goal of teaching was to direct children in `learning to learn,' whatever that means... "But--and this is most important--extra money put into the present system will be to no avail... "No high school teacher should be hired who has an undergraduate degree in education... "The teachers unions, and those they represent, and the Establishment of which they are a part, are the perpetrators, not the rescuers, of the failed American public education system." There are nearly three million school teachers in the US. They are as much the victims of the present system as their fifty million students. All teachers should read this book; they would know in their hearts that we can do so much better. Here's my explanation for our malaise: John Dewey (America's first stealth bomber) started a secret plot wherein love of ideology and power led to mendacity and mediocrity. Ordinary citizens, puzzled that schools are so inefficient, would probably be shocked to find that poor performance is not accidental but the planned result of deliberate policies. Our so-called educators pimp for dumb. The sticking point for many people is motives. Isn't it just that these educators are sort of stupid? A gang that can't shoot straight? Could there actually be a conspiracy? Isn't that too evil to think about? No, you just take a deep breath and repeat these words by Martin Gross: "[Educators] have taken control of our schools away from citizens, the parents, and their elected officials--who are generally naive about education and overwhelmed by the jargon and obfuscation of the Education Establishment. In most ways, that Establishment is an unscholarly, anti-intellectual, anti-academic cabal which can best be described as `a conspiracy of ignorance,' one with false theories and low academic standards." There! A conspiracy of ignorance, at the least. This excellent book, first published 8 years ago, is in some ways a complement to "The Dumbing Down Of Our Kids" by Charles Sykes. Both remain vibrant and vital because our educators, if anything, are doing a worse job. Here's the weird part for me: it's as if our educators don't live here. As they slowly sabotage the country, won't they also suffer? I always suspect there must be some crazy old Stalinists at the top. Who else could be so short-sighted? Here's where they've taken us: a government report last year said we are at a tipping point, that the public schools are so bad that our economic future is in jeopardy. I'm certain that the Chinese and Indians get up every morning thanking our daffy educators! A word to the wise: if you find that a political candidate is receiving a large contribution from the NEA, vote for somebody else.
A Blueprint For Saving The Public Schools April 2, 2008 Bruce Deitrick Price (Norfolk, Va.) Martin Gross provides a passionate, fact-filled investigation of the problems in the public schools at all levels. He has chapters on the training and licensing of teachers, the dumbed down curriculum, the psychologized classroom, the value of charter schools, the hope of alternative certification, the dead weight of the NEA, the betrayal by the PTA in many communities, and much more. Gross finishes with an excellent 19-point reform plan, which includes these items: modify tenure laws, close all undergraduate schools of education, regulate teacher unions, award more vouchers, disband the national, state and local PTA, and increase alternative certification. Gross points out that: "In inflation-adjusted dollars, we are now spending two to three times more per child than in 1960, when performance was generally higher.... "It is hard for laypeople to understand the level of intellectual blindness that dominates the education profession... "Are students and society better off with the weaker student-centered education of today? Only if we want to accept the trade-off of being among the most ignorant nations in the world... "The education professor in Connecticut whom I interviewed denigrated facts--or knowledge--as `trivia,' claiming that the main goal of teaching was to direct children in `learning to learn,' whatever that means... "But--and this is most important--extra money put into the present system will be to no avail... "No high school teacher should be hired who has an undergraduate degree in education... "The teachers unions, and those they represent, and the Establishment of which they are a part, are the perpetrators, not the rescuers, of the failed American public education system." There are nearly three million school teachers in the US. They are as much the victims of the present system as their fifty million students. All teachers should read this book; they would know in their hearts that we can do so much better. Here's my explanation for our malaise: John Dewey (America's first stealth bomber) started a secret plot wherein love of ideology and power led to mendacity and mediocrity. Ordinary citizens, puzzled that schools are so inefficient, would probably be shocked to find that poor performance is not accidental but the planned result of deliberate policies. Our so-called educators pimp for dumb. The sticking point for many people is motives. Isn't it just that these educators are sort of stupid? A gang that can't shoot straight? Could there actually be a conspiracy? Isn't that too evil to think about? No, you just take a deep breath and repeat these words by Martin Gross: "[Educators] have taken control of our schools away from citizens, the parents, and their elected officials--who are generally naive about education and overwhelmed by the jargon and obfuscation of the Education Establishment. In most ways, that Establishment is an unscholarly, anti-intellectual, anti-academic cabal which can best be described as `a conspiracy of ignorance,' one with false theories and low academic standards." There! A conspiracy of ignorance, at the least. This excellent book, first published 8 years ago, is in some ways a complement to "The Dumbing Down Of Our Kids" by Charles Sykes. Both remain vibrant and vital because our educators, if anything, are doing a worse job. Here's the weird part for me: it's as if our educators don't live here. As they slowly sabotage the country, won't they also suffer? I always suspect there must be some crazy old Stalinists at the top. Who else could be so short-sighted? Here's where they've taken us: a government report last year said we are at a tipping point, that the public schools are so bad that our economic future is in jeopardy. I'm certain that the Chinese and Indians get up every morning thanking our daffy educators! A word to the wise: if you find that a political candidate is receiving a large contribution from the NEA, vote for somebody else.
Teachers are stopping education progress July 26, 2007 Rick Johnson 0 out of 1 found this review helpful
Millionaire in 365 Days: The Daily Plan to Get There The teachers are improving their lot...and the students get shafted....not only is there a 180 day work year, but the subjects of what is being taught, the testing and all related is dumbing don, lower and lower....good research to back it up too....read it and weep.
And his scientific, scholarly evidence is where? March 15, 2007 R. C. Showman (Orlando, FL) 1 out of 7 found this review helpful
Apparently, Mr. Gross didn't even bother to step into a classroom in writing about the failing of our schools. His own anecdotal testimonies of what a "proper" secondary education should be like--many years after the fact and clouded by editorial discretion and selective memory--cannot possibly be held as the model against which today's schools are evaluated. That is faulty reasoning and logic. Had Mr. Gross paid attention in his own writing classes during undergraduate and graduate, he would know that this book is rife with logical fallacies, weak ad hominem attacks, lack of real evidence, and many more points of weakness. Granted, some of his critiques are valid and useful. His prescriptions, however, are utter failures in that they are based on...I've no idea, really. He accuses with only statistics to back him up. Such statistics only paint part of the picture. Despite a PhD in Social Policy (or whatever his degree), he does not look at other factors, such as the failing of the nuclear family structure, political hamstringing, incredible socio-economic obstacles, and many other problems that interfere with a teacher's ability to instruct. Of course, this is not the place to make a sophisticated, lengthy critique of Mr. Gross's argument--nonetheless, the book is dangerous in that it merely accuses teachers of being awful and some nebulous, ill-defined "Establishment" as propagating ills. Put simply, he analyzes statistics--and, as every statistics students knows, is a faulty enterprise (to copy & paste his own style of argument)--and draws incredible, far-reaching conclusions from there without due consideration of what it really is to be a teacher.
|
|
|
Proud member of the Celebrity Pro Network. Make sure you check out these other great JimmyKat network sites:
Lyrics Database
Celebrity Blog
Celebrity Thing
Celebrity PC
Latest Celebrity Photos
Web Portal
Travel Photos
Quotes
Flash Games
|
Is there a better price available?
Find out:
|
|
|
|